4.9
From 1
to 5
Reviews
11629
Recommend
10 / 10
TrustScore
9.9 / 10
Steven Lawrence
Verified Buyer
Prime Rib Roast
5 stars says it’s all good
Bruce Conley
Verified Buyer
Prime Rib Roast
First time ordering the prime rib and will not be the last! everyone raved on the flavor so much better than store bought!
Thanks again!
Thanks again!
Tracy Vargo
Verified Buyer
Chicken Wings
Best chicken wings I’ve tried ! Very meaty amid moist! Thank you!
Mike Imperiale
Verified Buyer
Prime Rib Roast
Great Steak! All I did was add salt, pepper, and a little bit of olive oil. I roasted slowly in a 250 degree oven until the internal temp was 120. Perfect Medium Rare. Thanks Dan!
Carol McAllister
Verified Buyer
Prime Rib Roast
Farmer Dan has the best meat around and that prime rib for Christmas was superb!! All meat has been the best! Customer service is excellent!
Thanks for all you do.
Thanks for all you do.
Brenda Haskell
Verified Buyer
Prime Rib Roast (3 lb average) $89 - New subscribers only
I roasted your prime rib for Christmas dinner and it was a huge success - so delicious and tender. It is hard to describe how much nicer the flavor and texture was when compared with supermarket meats. All I can say is for folks to try it and they won't be disappointed.
Response from Heartstone Farm
Dec 27, 2022
Brenda - Thanks for your kind review - I am glad to hear you enjoyed your Roast. Merry Christmas to you and your family. - Dan
Christopher Fraser
Verified Buyer
Beef Shares
Always very happy with the meat. Beyond my expectations!
Christopher Fraser
Verified Buyer
Prime Rib Roast
Great Prime rib very tender and amazing taste!!
Denise Knue
Verified Buyer
Prime Rib Roast
It was fabulous. Tender and the meat was marbled nicely. Juicy and very enjoyable. We will definately buy another next year. We cooked it smothered with compound garlic butter in a cast iron pan with quartered onion and bulb garlic with a little Rosemary and thyme sprinkled over it. It was heavenly. Thank you Farmer Dan we love your product and will be forever customers.
Frank Muraca
Verified Buyer
Maine Surf and Turf
Our surf n turf dinner was excellent !! I wish we had taken a photo - it was photo worthy believe me !! Farmer Can never disappoints with his Heartstone quality . From the beautifully boxed holiday meal at delivery to the superb flavors, it was A+. As always......Thank you Farmer Dan and staff ! Frank & Kristy Muraca
Randy Yerman
Verified Buyer
Prime Rib Roast (3 lb average) $89 - New subscribers only
Everyone enjoyed the prime, came packaged well and had no complaints.
Laura Levin
Verified Buyer
Prime Rib Roast
This one was challenging but only because we lost power and were on the generator for Christmas Eve. So here is the story of our Christmas Eve Heartstone Farm Prime Rib Roast, mistakes and all:
I could not use our oven but could use my mom's ancient electric skillet roaster and our air fryer for side dishes. I had to call my sister to google the method for me since we also lost internet. So I trimmed the fat as instructed and probably went too far. Then I seasoned the meat simply with salt, pepper, and garlic powder. The instructions were to preheat and roast covered for 35 minutes then turn it off and leave for an hour. Did that and should have only roasted for 20 minutes due to the lower weight than used in the recipe since it over cooked, which I know is a crime for prime rib. Maybe one or two slices got some of that nice deep pink. It was still quite tasty with homemade horsey sauce, air fried pomp frites with homemade mayo aioli, and air fried Brussels sprouts. I'm going to use some of the leftovers to make a beef chili. Next time, I won't trim so much fat and will roast for a shorter time, depending on the weight...and hopefully use my oven!
5 stars because it wasn't the meat but the circumstances and me.
I could not use our oven but could use my mom's ancient electric skillet roaster and our air fryer for side dishes. I had to call my sister to google the method for me since we also lost internet. So I trimmed the fat as instructed and probably went too far. Then I seasoned the meat simply with salt, pepper, and garlic powder. The instructions were to preheat and roast covered for 35 minutes then turn it off and leave for an hour. Did that and should have only roasted for 20 minutes due to the lower weight than used in the recipe since it over cooked, which I know is a crime for prime rib. Maybe one or two slices got some of that nice deep pink. It was still quite tasty with homemade horsey sauce, air fried pomp frites with homemade mayo aioli, and air fried Brussels sprouts. I'm going to use some of the leftovers to make a beef chili. Next time, I won't trim so much fat and will roast for a shorter time, depending on the weight...and hopefully use my oven!
5 stars because it wasn't the meat but the circumstances and me.
Response from Heartstone Farm
Dec 26, 2022
Laura - Thanks for sharing - sounds like it will be a Christmas Eve to remember. You deserve credit for persevering and I am sure it was delicious. Merry Christmas! - Dan
Donna Cooke
Verified Email
Prime Rib Roast
Looked great, cooked exactly as recommended .sorry to say it was very tough all the way through. Tried to upload photos but found no place to do that.
Dawn Stammers
Verified Buyer
Prime Rib Roast (3 lb average) $89 - New subscribers only
Roast was tender and flavorful. Ive not had anything from Hearthstone
Farm that wasnt amazing. Shipping was fast, as always. Packing materials top notch.
Farm that wasnt amazing. Shipping was fast, as always. Packing materials top notch.
Response from Heartstone Farm
Dec 26, 2022
Dawn - That roast looks perfect - thanks for sharing! Merry Christmas. - Dan
Laura Collins
Verified Buyer
Prime Rib Roast
This was a spectacular prime rib! The quality was outstanding! The entire family enjoyed our holiday meal! We will be repeat customers!!
Carol Domingue
Verified Buyer
Prime Rib Roast
Best prime rib, did not disappoint at all. Happy I found this farm and all the wonderful products available close to home.
Carol Domingue
Verified Buyer
Bone-In Pasture-Raised Smoked Ham
Best ham and prime rib, did not disappoint at all. Made a great meal for the holiday. Will be buying again. Happy Holidays!
Response from Heartstone Farm
Dec 26, 2022
Carol - That feast looks delicious - thanks for sharing! Merry Christmas. - Dan
Barry Edith
Verified Buyer
Filet Mignon
I love Filet Mignon, but I found these filets were under whelming.
First: They were small and shaped odd.
Second: They had a strip of fat going down the center.
Third: I thought they had mistakenly put stew beef in the package or steak tip.
I'm a fan of Hearthstone farms meat, but not these underwelming filets.
Update: I thawed the filets and cooked them. Delicious!!!!! I retract my previous review. These steaks were delicious, tender, and high quality. I will refrain from doing reviews in the future until I have thawed and tasted the product. I would order these again.
First: They were small and shaped odd.
Second: They had a strip of fat going down the center.
Third: I thought they had mistakenly put stew beef in the package or steak tip.
I'm a fan of Hearthstone farms meat, but not these underwelming filets.
Update: I thawed the filets and cooked them. Delicious!!!!! I retract my previous review. These steaks were delicious, tender, and high quality. I will refrain from doing reviews in the future until I have thawed and tasted the product. I would order these again.
Response from Heartstone Farm
Dec 23, 2022
Barry - I am very sorry to hear you were disappointed by the Filets. One thing to mention - they are not cut by our processor in the typical way of a small piece of round meat - the way they often are in restaurants. We cut them what I guess I would call naturally. They can sometimes have a bit of a fat in them. I was wondering how you liked them - despite the cosmetic flaws. Thanks for your support - and, of course, your feedback. - Dan
Scott Tremble
Verified Buyer
Beef Shares
Excellent service and met our expectations! Everything was delivered well organized and fully frozen.
david schroeder
Verified Buyer
Our Best Steaks Sampler
Once again we cross paths with a great product and appreciative review. This sampler was shared with two neighbors who just thought it was terrific. I’ll be back to order more!!!!
About Heartstone Farm
All natural beef, chicken and pork - from our farm in Maine to your table
Visit Website
Heartstone Farm is a Verified Merchant
Questions? Contact Us
dan@heartstonefarm.me
207-424-0063
Top Rated Products
|
Farmer Dan's Meat Bo... |
|
|
Premium Ground Beef |
|
|
Ground Beef |
|
Facebook
RaveCapture Commitment
RaveCapture transforms how businesses collect and showcase customer experiences. We take authenticity seriously and only allow 100% verified buyer reviews and UGC.
Guarantee
- RaveCapture Companies Are Held Accountable
- All Reviews Are Verified Customers
- Negative Reviews Can Never Be Deleted
With RaveCapture, you’re not just managing a reputation — you’re sharing the voice of your raving fans.