Heartstone Farm https://heartstonefarm.com/ Food & Gourmet
4.8 From 1 to 5
1701 Reviews
Overall Ratings
5 Stars
1521
4 Stars
84
3 Stars
33
2 Stars
27
1 Star
36
Reviews 1701
Recommend 10 / 10
TrustScore 9.7 / 10
edward otero
Oct 19, 2020
Verified Buyer
The order came on time and was prefect!! The ribeye steaks and the chicken were amazing. Customer service were the sweetest people in the world!!! Thank you so much!!!
James Haugh
Oct 15, 2020
.
Walter Allen
Oct 11, 2020
Verified Buyer
I purchased 2 Porterhouse steaks, 2 Filet Mignon's, 2 strip steaks, and 1 chuck roast. They arrived fast,were frozen solid and were packed beautifully. We have tried the Porterhouse and the Filets. The Porterhouse Steaks are about 1/2" thick (I'm used to at least 1-1/2" Thick so right off the bat I was pretty disappointed). But I figured, let's try them, they could be great . . . sadly it was not to be. The whole thing (strip & filet) were tasty BUT just as tough as nails. So that was a big thumbs down. Next we tried the filets on the grill (the Porterhouses were just too thin for the grill, at a half inch). The Fillets cooked up great and smelled wonderful . . . however, they too were just as tough as nails! What a disappointment! We haven't tried the strip steaks or the chuck roast yet but I'm pretty nervous at this point. I feel bad writing this review because I really want to support local farmers/producers BUT if they are going to charge premium prices I expect a premium product and sadly, so far I feel really let down by how tough the meat was. A Filet should be just as tender as can be! I have been able to cut many Filets with my fork, on these 2 we had to saw through them with our serrated steak knives -- no way a fork would do it! Also, I emailed the company to ask if we might be able to get a 1-1/2" special cut Porterhouse but 5 days later I'm still waiting for a reply. Perhaps it's just as well at this point . . .
Response from Heartstone Farm
Oct 12, 2020
Walter - Thanks for taking the time to give your honest feedback. I want to respond first about the Porterhouses - we got a batch in two weeks ago which were uncharacteristically thin (as you noticed). Typically our Porterhouses are about 1" thick. So - first things first - I am going to send you our "normal sized" Porterhouses this week. We'll try to be more careful about letting such thin steaks out in the future. As to the filets - frankly I am surprised because it is always such a tender steak. I don't have a good explanation on that one :(. I have issued you a refund for the filets. You mentioned "Strip Steaks" in your review - but you ordered and received Sirloin Tip steak. This is one of our "marinating steaks" - less tender than our premium steaks and best cooked low and slow and with a marinade. You definitely want to be careful about cooking them on the grill because that will definitely make them less tender - especially with high heat. And I hope you'll let me know on the Chuck Roast. So we will send you a replacement "thick" Porterhouse. And we have refunded you for the filets. I am sorry to hear about your experience - but we'll do our best to make it right. - Dan
Nancy Newberry
Sep 18, 2020
Verified Buyer
Heartstone Farms delivers the best , the beef tastes like real food ! Every meat product arrives frozen and best of all it is a Maine farm . Nan Newberry
Response from Heartstone Farm
Sep 25, 2020
Thanks for your kind review Nan - it means a lot to us to have your support. - Dan
Eli Grober
Sep 18, 2020
Verified Buyer
If you're looking for a consistent meat guy, Farmer Dan never disappoints!
Ann Oliver
Sep 18, 2020
Verified Buyer
What a special treat this amazing steak was!! Dealing with Farmer Dan and his family of caring, enthusiastic, responsive family is a true pleasure. The meat is otherworldly, the delivery 🚚 is reliable to the minute, the packaging is environmentally responsible (is it possible to have you pick up and re-use the boxes, padding and ice packets on our next order??), and the whole idea of cows well loved and raised in a wholesome environment where they’re happy makes buying beef from any other source unthinkable ❤️ We love you guys!!! 🐄❤️
Karen S. Haynes
Sep 15, 2020
.
Robin Vaccaro
Sep 15, 2020
Verified Buyer
Best grass fed beef ever!!! We searched for local grass fed beef and we came across Heartstone farm. I am very happy with the flavor and customer service!! Thank you Farmer Dan! I will continue ordering from Heartstone! I just ordered one of the subscription boxes !
Rene Risher-Kelly
Sep 14, 2020
Verified Buyer
Have tried many meat delivery services from supposedly grassfed better products. This place is the absolute best. Every cut of meat I have purchased has been off the charts excellent most recently even the hangar steak ! I order all my meat from them now.
Ann Gary Oliver
Sep 06, 2020
What an absolutely amazing family business :-) We moved from California to Portland last winter and I discovered Farmer Dan and his wonderful crew while seeking for humanely treated animals from which to eat small quantities of meat; something we’ve been trying to give up. While in a perfect world I’d be a vegetarian, I lack the discipline to do that and finding this magnificent farm with the most extraordinary meat I’ve ever tasted has done much to preserve our family’s conscience. Any questions are immediately answered, everyone who works there is kind, respectful, and delightful to deal with. I am spreading the word to all of my friends and family that there is no better place to purchase meat than one where the animals are treated with love and kindness and raised in a truly beautiful environment. We absolutely love Heartstone Farm ????
Sonya Sampson
Sep 03, 2020
Verified Buyer
I have been buying beef from Heartstone farm for about three years. Every single box is filled with pure bliss. The high quality beef is exactly what I wanted for my family. I know many people will say, but it is so expensive....let me say that I would rather have less per portion of the best beef there is than a plateful of beef that you don't know how it is treated. Thank you, thank you, thank you. and may I say...I so appreciate that you took it on yourself to obtain such high quality organic chicken. Your dedication to high quality food makes it a joy to purchase from you. Sonya Sampson, a dedicated buyer.
Hunter Shaak
Aug 23, 2020
Verified Buyer
Some of the best beef I have ever eaten. The quality of the meats from Heartstone are unbelievable.
Lisa Moll
Aug 15, 2020
.
seth trudeau
Aug 09, 2020
Verified Buyer
Great quality, great price, perfect taste. I will be a long time customer. Keep up the great service and I will continue to buy and recommend your product to others. Thank you for you hard work. God bless
Barbara Lubas
Aug 08, 2020
Verified Buyer
Always fresh and tasty
James Haugh
Jul 27, 2020
Package arrived frozen hard. Product wonderful. Unlike beef finished on corn this grass fed beef is a bit sweeter to my taste. Recommend.
Danny Smith
Jul 09, 2020
Verified Buyer
This is high quality food with excellent taste. You won't go wrong purchasing from Heartstone Farms.
Joseph Dupuis
Jul 08, 2020
Verified Buyer
Wonderful meat!!!
John Pope
Jul 07, 2020
Verified Buyer
Superior Beef with Exceptional Service
Sherrie Downing
Jul 07, 2020
Verified Buyer
We love the beef and chicken we get from Heartstone Farms. It's nice to have a farm near you that delivers excellent products. Thank you Heartstone!
About Heartstone Farm
All natural beef, chicken and pork - from our farm in Maine to your table
Visit Website
Heartstone Farm is a Verified Merchant
Questions? Contact Us
dan@heartstonefarm.me
207-424-0063
Facebook
RaveCapture Commitment
RaveCapture transforms how businesses collect and showcase customer experiences. We take authenticity seriously and only allow 100% verified buyer reviews and UGC.
Guarantee
  1. RaveCapture Companies Are Held Accountable
  2. All Reviews Are Verified Customers
  3. Negative Reviews Can Never Be Deleted
With RaveCapture, you’re not just managing a reputation — you’re sharing the voice of your raving fans.
RaveCapture loader